When it comes to lifting and moving heavy loads, hoists are an essential tool.
There are a range of both manual and electric hoists out on the market, but how do you decide which one you need to use? This blog will unpack the key differences between electric and manual hoists so that you can make an informed choice on which tool is best for your specific lifting needs.
What Is a Manual Hoist?
Manual hoists, also known as chain blocks or hand chain hoists, are a type of hoist that is operated using human power. The user pulls on the hand chain in order to lift or lower the load through a system of gears. The gears multiply the applied force, allowing the user to lift heavy loads with minimal effort. The load is supported by a brake mechanism that holds it securely in place.
Manual Hoist Pros
- No power source is required, so manual hoists can be used anywhere, regardless of electricity access
- Compact and portable
- Easy to maintain and repair on-site
- Typically made from durable steel and can withstand harsh conditions
- Ideal for precise load positioning
- Lower cost and therefore a more affordable initial investment
Manual Hoist Cons
- Slower lifting speeds
- Requires physical effort, particularly with heavier loads
- Less efficient for frequent or heavy-duty lifting
- Can lead to fatigue which can increase the risk of errors
- Many models are designed for lifting only, not pulling
What Is an Electric Hoist?
An electric hoist uses an electric motor or battery to lift and lower loads automatically. The operator uses a control pendant, push-button or remote system to control the lifting or lowering of the load. Electric and battery powered hoists feature built-in safety brakes to prevent accidental load drops.
Electric Hoist Pros
- Reduced operator fatigue and strain
- Designed to handle higher load capacities
- Consistent performance for repetitive tasks
- Fast and efficient lifting that leads to increased productivity
- Can be used for both vertical and horizontal lifting with ease
Electric Hoist Cons
- Higher upfront cost
- Requires electricity or battery power to operate
- Heavier and less portable than manual hoists
- More complex to maintain and repair
How to Choose Between a Manual and Electric Hoist
When deciding whether your task requires a manual or electric hoist, consider the following factors:
Frequency of Use
If you only need to do occasional or light-duty lifting, a manual hoist is the most cost effective option. If you need to carry out frequent or continuous lifting, an electric hoist will improve your productivity and reduce worker strain.
Load Weight
If you are lifting a heavy load, you will want to opt for an electric or battery powered hoist. If you are lifter a lighter load, it can most likely be handled safely with a manual hoist.
Electricity Access
If you have no access to power or electricity, you will need to use a manual hoist or ensure that you have a pre-charged battery powered hoist at your disposal. If you have access to power, an electric hoist may be the easier option.
Portability
If you will be working on a mobile or temporary jobsite, a manual hoist or pre-charged battery powered hoist is probably your best bet. Electric hoists, on the other hand, work best when mounted onto cranes and gantries or in more permanent setups.
At SafetyLiftinGear, we stock a range of electrical, battery powered and manual hoists for you to choose from – use the buttons below to browse our selection.
Shop Electrical Hoists Shop Manual Hoists Shop Battery Powered Hoists
0117 9381 600
